(Now working) Are Amex Membership Rewards transfers to Hawaiian Airlines dead?

112

Update 9/27/24: We’ve now received multiple reports of folks getting Amex/Hawaiian transfers to work, with the miles displaying instantly in their Hawaiian accounts. It looks like some have been able to do it online even after repeatedly getting error messages and others have been successful via chat rep.

~~~

Uh-oh.

There’s been a lot of anticipation (and speculation) about what would happen with American Express Membership Rewards transfers to Hawaiian Airlines once it became possible to transfer HawaiianMiles to Alaska Mileage Plan. Alaska has never been a partner of a major transferable currency (sorry Bilt), and once transfers became possible from Hawaiian to Alaska, it would effectively mean that you could transfer Membership Rewards to Alaska.

Well, Hawaiian/Alaska transfers are now live…and Amex/Hawaiian isn’t working.

Online, attempts to transfer lead to an error message:

At first I thought that this might be because of increased volume due to the Alaska/Hawaiian transfer going live, but I didn’t have issues with any of Amex’s other partners.

So, I got help from an Amex chat rep and was successfully able to transfer 1,000 points to Hawaiian with their help…only to have those points instantly refunded:

That’s not a good sign.

Quick Thoughts

Greg and Nick discussed whether or not the Amex/Hawaiian transfer would eventually end, and when, on last week’s Frequent Miler on the Air. They both agreed that the most likely scenario would be that it would go away next year sometime when the programs combined, but that there was a small chance it might die as soon as you could move HawaiianMiles to Alaska. Could the longshot actually be happening?

It could still be that this is simply a temporary technical issue. If anyone is able to successfully make a transfer, please let us know in the comments (and tell us if you did it online or with a rep).

Want to learn more about miles and points? Subscribe to email updates or check out our podcast on your favorite podcast platform.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

112 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

[…] oh: Are Amex Membership Rewards transfers to Hawaiian Airlines dead? […]

Jim

I did 2 transfers from Amex to Hawaiian. Did a test 5K transfer; then another 135K. Both went through almost instantly. From there, I was able to transfer these points over to Alaska immediately. Thanks to FM for the valuable guidance along the way!

Max Miles Points

I was able to transfer Amex points to Hawaiian on 10/01/24 at 3:42 PM PT
I transferred 1,000 Amex Points online and got a confirmation email a few seconds later, and points showed up in the Hawaiian account instantly.

Sam

Fine, I caved and transferred 70k pts to Hawaiian just in case. I do think there’s probably still some run way on these MR to Hawaiian transfers though.
Would suck if Alaska suddenly devalued.

Last edited 8 days ago by Sam
Diana

failed for me every time until I read the comments below and chatted with an Amex rep. 350,000 MP later I’ve successfully transferred them to Hawaiian. Thank you FM!

Roland L

Worked for me, transferred 50K to Hawaiian, Hawaiian to AS immediately

David C

Frequentmiler guys are awesome! I love using alaskan airline pts. Last week, redeemed 27.5K Alaskan pts one-way flights each (family of 6) to go from MSP to CDGfor may 27th via Iceland air. Alaskan points were getting very low, but you guys made my day! after 7 attempts and following some helpful hints at this comment section, I was able to transfer Amex pts to Hawaiian 1:1 plus $99 Amex fee (yes, I transferred over 500K amex pts). So, today this was what happend in 20 minutes time frame: I just created Hawaiian account right before my first failed attempt to transfer. Did it on PC. Failed to registered the account for pts transfer. Showed up error screen like the example Frequentmiler listed above. Tried several more time and still same result. Then took my android amex app and was able to successfully add the Hawaiian acct. However, was not able to transfer amex pts to Hawaiian as the same error popped up several more time. I thought all was lost, but I gave it another try by switching back to my PC and signing into the amex login. Proceeded to transfer pts and it workd the first time! The rest was pretty straight forward when the pts posted into the hawaiian account in 1 minute time. I then clicked on the transfer link located in my Hawaiian acct and scrolled the blue selection tab to Alaska miles (transfer point into Alaska acct). Within less than 1 minute, my alaskan acct showed up the transferred pts. I hope this info help. You guys rock with your strategies! Keep trying and do not give up!

Jay

Worked for me. Transferred 81k MR to HA then to AS

fa sa

why is there a rush to do it now? are people thinking amex will remove hawaiian airline transfer?

Jay

Yes

Jayson

Worked for me. Today I transferred 30k MR points to Hawaiian and then to Alaska.

Jamon

Did amex charge u a fee to transfer the points to Hawaiian?

rick b

There’s always the 0.6% fee, no way to avoid it. It’s capped at $99 so doing 200k+ transfer is better

Jamon

Bet, Thanks!!!!

Jayson

Yes. Amex charge for all transfers to US Domestic Mileage Programs ( Hawaiian, Delta, Jet Blue)

Thats been in place for years.

Cary

It finally worked for me this afternoon after several failures last night and this morning. Transferred 24k miles.

Ahsan

Just transferred 58k

Randy

Two failures and a success on the morning of 9/27/24. First was error screen. Second was a identity check that was failing even with correct info. Third, ended up going to chat and they made the transfer for me. Instant Success!

Michael

I had to try a few times in the amex app, but it eventually worked for me too (transfer from amex to hawaiian)

Luke

throw in another DP for transfer success. I successfully transferred Amex—> Hawaiian just now, desktop, no error