This is the latest in our ongoing series of what’s new in the world of manufactured spending. Our last update was in December (here).
As always, you can find an up-to-date complete roundup of techniques for increasing spend here: Manufactured Spending Complete Guide.
Options no longer with us
Cue up the funeral march: these are options that have ended since our previous update.
Citi AT&T Access More No Longer Earns 3x at Paypal Digital Gifts
The Citi AT&T Access More card hasn’t been available for new applications in a long time, but I believe it is still available for product changes. Last year, Citi announced that they would no longer pay out 3x on most manufactured spending opportunities, including the purchases of gift cards. Unfortunately, they finally caught up with PPDG and have stopped paying 3x on statements cutting in March.
What still works?
The AT&T Access More card still earns 3x on many online retail and travel purchases. While many gift card options have died, the card can still be useful when a mainstream online store has a gift card sale (like Amazon.com) and it continues to stack well with 3x JetBlue points for Amazon purchases. Some Plastiq payments may still be coding at 3x, but I have seen increased reports of the last few people with working 3x mortgage payments now earning only 1x. In my experience, a Plastiq payment that had still earned 3x in January finally stopped as of my February statement. This card seems best for merchandise resellers and those who shop often at major online stores (though do your research to be sure your chosen store will earn 3x).
Amex terms now exclude earning points on cash equivalents, Amex Gift Cards purchased online, and person-to-person payments
The terms on Membership Rewards-earning cards have been updated to exclude certain transactions from earning points. You’ll likely still earn points on merchant gift cards (i.e. Amazon gift cards, Best Buy gift cards, etc), but the terms now clearly exclude most types of Visa/Mastercard/Amex gift cards — even Amex Gift Cards purchased directly from Amex (which is odd considering the fact that this just encourages you to pay with a non-Amex card). Further, payments through Venmo or other similar peer-to-peer payment platforms are now excluded. We don’t yet have many datapoints as to whether or how this is being enforced — time will tell.
What still works?
I expect that merchant gift cards are still a safe purchase on Amex cards, but the terms are sufficiently vague to claw back points if your spending patterns deviate too far from the norm. Most co-branded cards do not yet have these newly expanded exclusions in the terms, so you may still be able to earn rewards in a broader set of categories with those. That said, I see the exclusion on the purchase or reloading of prepaid cards or purchase of cash equivalents exclusion on all of the cards I’ve checked. That language has been around for a while, but Amex seems to be making movements toward enforcing it. It’s probably best to use other cards for these types of purchases.
Update to Manufactured Spending Complete Guide:Many readers wonder what methods still work for meeting minimum spend for signup bonuses on Amex cards. Our Manufactured Spending Complete Guide now includes a section titled, Which Techniques are Safe for Meeting Amex Minimum Spend? |
No more 5x at MPX
Purchases through the United MileagePlus X app have stopped coding at 5x on the Amex Platinum card. While purchases still appear categorized as airfare, the bonus points have not posted — thus it seems that Amex has finally cut MPX out as an option for 5x spend.
What still works?
According to reports in our Laboratory, the Citi AT&T Access More card continues to earn 3x in the MPX app.
Alliant paying 0% cash back at Giftcards.com
The Alliant Visa carries a very generous 3% cash back the first year and 2.5% back thereafter. While it was a great card for manufactured spend, they recently sent letters to those putting heavy spend on the cards with a warning that accounts will be shut down with further heavy use. It remains to be seen how this will play out and what the affect will be on in-person gift card purchases.
What still works?
There are still many in-person merchants at which you can buy gift cards and likely earn 3% cash back. However, the risk is two-fold: Alliant may shut down your account and/or they may void your rewards. Before purchasing a significant amount of gift cards, one should weigh the risk of Alliant suddenly deciding to award 0% as they did with Giftcards.com purchases. I think this will likely still work for in-person purchases that match up with your stated income, but those who spend well beyond their stated means may get shut out.
Another one down: No more 5x at Gift Card Mart
Gift Card Mart joined the list of merchants that no longer code for 5x on Chase Ink cards.
What still works?
See this post: What’s left for 5X Ink?
You can no longer buy Amazon GCs with Gamestop GCs
This was nice while it lasted, but it seems it’s been hardcoded for the register to reject Gamestop gift cards for payment.
What still works?
The Marvel Credit Card should still earn 3% back at Gamestop. Mostly, this one appears to be dead.
Old Blue no more
We bid adieu to an old friend: The “Old” Blue Cash card. The application page appears to have finally stopped working and redirecting to newer cards. So long, farewell, goodbye.
Walmart Money Order fee increase
Some Walmart stores have increased the fee for money orders from $0.70 to $0.88. The money-order fees are not standardized nationwide, so the fee will still potentially vary, but you’ll want to remember to check if you’re looking to keep your total to an even-dollar figure.
No more credit card MQMs for Delta Status Challenge
While you could previously complete a Delta Status Challenge with MQMs earned from a credit card signup bonus and/or Big Spend Bonus, that won’t fly anymore. More accurately, you now need to fly.
New methods
A couple of new MS opportunities have recently popped up:
Pay Rent with RoomiPay
Health Assessment: Healthy and easy
Cost: This blog page (which says it has been updated this week) indicates 2%, but this blog post claims that payments for April will open on March 15th with a new fee structure as follows:
- First 50 people pay no fee
- Next 150 people = 2% fee
- Next 100 people = 2.5% fee
- Everyone else = 3% fee
Technique brief summary: Pay rent via credit card for a 2% fee.
More detail: As long as they offer a 2% fee, this service has an obvious edge over Plastiq and Rentler (both of which charge 2.5%). If the new fee structure is correct, this will only appeal to the fastest 50. Sign up here to be notified when they begin taking payments for April. Readers have confirmed that the charge shows up as an online computer software store. You’ll want to use a card that earns a bonus on computer software stores or at online retail merchants to maximize return.
Pay Rent with Cirtru
Health Assessment: Healthy and easy
Cost: The regular fee is 3%. They were recently running a fee-free promo for listed rentals.
Technique brief summary: Pay rent with a credit card.
More detail: A few days ago, Cirtru was running a promo for no credit card fee when paying for listed rentals (see post linked under “cost”). It looks like that promotion has ended. At 3%, this would not be a deal compared to other options — but if the fee-free option returns, this would be a great way to earn some points if you can pay for a listed rental.
What else still works?
In terms of increasing your credit card spend and getting most of it back, there are still lots of ways to do so. In addition to things discussed above, some healthy options remain:
- Fund College Savings or Student Loans with Gift of College gift cards
- Pay Federal Taxes
- Pay Friends with Venmo or Paypal
- Pay Rent with RadPad
- Pay Rent with Rentler
- Kiva Loans
- Reselling
Our Manufactured Spending Complete Guide lists a number of other options that may or may not be available or appeal to you depending on your location and appetite for risk. The landscape is constantly changing, but our guide remains a living resource to find what still works in March 2018 and beyond. If you’re looking for further discussion about what works, one place to connect with others may be our Frequent Miler Insiders Facebook group.
[…] Manufacture spend is a way to spend money on credit cards and get most of the money back. Tricks include; buying gift cards with credit cards and later cashing out the gift cards, funding Paypal accounts with credit cards, etc. In the last year or two these tricks are becoming harder and harder to do. Nick from the Frequent Miler has a great page on which tricks still work in 2018. You can check out the page here. […]
I has bought 14k in gift cards from giftcards.com. I carried them on my trip to Florida recently. Used a few of my gift cards.. Used a few to transfer the funds via venmo. After transfer I destroyed the cards and threw them. Venmo has frozen my account and has transferred the money back to the card that I had used.. Is there a way to get that card details back I have lost $3000…. Please help… Don’t have more details.. Will giftcards. Com be of any help
I’m honestly not sure. I guess your only option is to contact giftcards.com. Sorry I can’t be of more assistance. It doesn’t help you now, but this kind of sutuation is part of the reason why I keep the cards even after they are drained.
Just curious, but why don’t you list “Fund bank accounts with a credit card” as still active for all CCs, but no longer counts towards MSR for Amex?
Sorry for the slow response on this. Good suggestion for the next guide!
[…] situation. For the purposes of this post, I’m going to assume that you follow our updates on How to increase credit card spend and get most of it back. What still works? and our Manufactured Spending Complete Guide so that it’s not an either/or […]
Nick, I read the whole MS Complete Guide as well as this and I’m unclear on one point: you don’t mention Gift of College cards as an Amex strategy. I have loans to repay and 529 contributions to make. Is there any sign of Amex current attitude toward GOC gift cards? Or any reason not to directly fund giftofcollege.com accounts with an Amex? The site seems to allow that.
Sorry for the slow response on this. I’m not aware of any issue with using Amex for GOC, but the cards are only available in a couple of regional stores right now and the fees to load online are high.
[…] It’s possible it’ll still work for some, but based on reports from friends as well as Frequentmiler and Outandout it looks like it stopped working for […]
[…] Increase credit card spend and get most of it back. What still works March 2018? […]
[…] is left of manufactured spending you […]
Simon VGC and Paypal both not working toward min spend on Amex BGR
It appears we may be losing the opportunity to buy the GofC cards at ToysRUs. TRU is closing down their stores because they cannot restructure
Hopefully, another store will take up the slack.
[…] percent off on a Lowe’s gift card isn’t a bad deal. As noted in our morning post (See: Increase credit card spend and get most of it back. What still works March 2018?), you may even be able to earn a category bonus. This is a small win, but an easy win nonetheless […]
Any issue paying Fed taxes with AMEX based on the new terms?
No. See the section referenced in the post in our Manufactured Spending Complete Guide (section titled: Which Techniques are Safe for Meeting Amex Minimum Spend?). Paying taxes is normal everyday behavior. I don’t think Amex is aiming to exclude “normal” behavior.
If I buy VGCs at a grocery store with an Amex, does Amex know what I bought? Are they able to separate VGCs from lamb meat?
Yes the receive level 3 data from the retailer.
As Bob said, they certainly may. If you Google Level 3 data as Bob references, you’ll see that it’s highly possible that they do know exactly what you bought (and in fact on my business card statements, it sometimes details exactly what I purchased).
I guess I’ll try buying the grocery store’s own gift card, then buy a VGC with that.
Two things:
#1: Make a test purchase on that first. Most places won’t let you buy a VGC with a merchant GC.
#2: I’m not sure this is a materially different strategy. Amex will still see that you’re buying GCs. If you’re doing this in large volume, they may consider the store cards to be cash equivalents / gift cards (or they may not). YMMV.