Frequent Miler's latest team challenge, Million Mile Madness, is happening now! Follow us as Greg, Nick, and Stephen compete to earn 1 Million SAS miles by flying 15 airlines before November 23rd. Who will complete the challenge with the most Speed, Affordability, and Style?
I knew that the general idea of Delta’s new elite requirements seemed to follow United and AA’s lead (see: Delta’s 2024 elite program – it ain’t pretty), but until I started crunching the numbers I didn’t realize that Delta must have literally copied United’s numbers and then applied a few tweaks. Let me show you what I found…
MQDs = PQPs + 20%
Take a look at this. Except for top-tier Diamond status, Delta’s new MQD requirements are exactly 20% more than United’s PQPs.
| Elite Level | United PQP Requirements | Delta MQD Requirements | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Silver | $5K | $6K | Delta is 20% higher |
| Gold | $10K | $12K | Delta is 20% higher |
| Platinum | $15K | $18K | Delta is 20% higher |
| Top Tier | $24K | $35K | Delta is 46% higher |
It’s pretty blatant, isn’t it? I bet when Delta first determined the requirements they penciled in $24K x 1.2 = $28,800 for Diamond, but then decided to multiply by 1.2 again to get to 34,560, and then they rounded off to $35K.
Credit Card Spend Matches Perfectly
Here’s where it gets even more interesting. United offers 500 PQPs per $12K spend on a number of credit cards. So, even though there are caps on how many PQPs you can earn (unless you have the old Presidential Plus Card), we can project how much spend is required to earn each status level if there were no caps and if you earn status entirely through credit card spend. Check this out:
| Elite Level | United Card Spend | Delta Platinum Card Spend | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Silver | $120K | $120K | None |
| Gold | $240K | $240K | None |
| Platinum | $360K | $360K | None |
| Top Tier | $576K | $700K | Delta is 22% higher |
The credit card spend required for Silver, Gold, and Platinum are exactly the same!
Here, obviously Delta wants to encourage people to get and put spend on the Delta Reserve card because with that card you can earn status with half the spend shown above.
Coincidence? No way
I don’t think there’s any way that it can be coincidence that Delta’s new requirements for the first three levels of elite status track perfectly with United’s. I would have expected Delta to put more thought in this, but instead we can plainly see where they got their inspiration and their detailed numbers.
Want to learn more about miles and points? Subscribe to email updates or check out our podcast on your favorite podcast platform.
anyone spending 576k on a UA card to get 1k and forego cash back is dumb
– anyone doing 700k on a DL platinum card is insane
I find it odd that the billions on dollars spend on analytics in the loyalty arena can’t grasp the concept of turning frequent customers into owners by allowing some/all of their loyalty currency converted into stock shares of the issuing company… who’s a more loyal customer than an owner?
@ Greg — Excellent analysis. I bet that DL only made their top level requirement higher to make up for the rollover MQM to MQD conversion, essentially meaning DL is confiscating rollover MQMs. Typical Delta behavior. What will Delta do once they have run out of things to steal from their customers?
I think you’re overthinking it. When you’re talking about numbers at the nearest thousand, everything is going to seem coincidental. You could make the argument they just increased their own requirements from 2019 for Silver, Gold, and Platinum by 100%, and Diamond by 133%. Or you could say that UA blatantly copied DL’s 2019 thresholds but raised them all by 66%. That’s just the math when you’re talking about “marketing friendly ” numbers.
I get your point and I think it is possibly a coincidence with regards to the MQD requirements, but the credit card spend stuff seems like an amazing coincidence if that’s what it is.
By the way, Silver, Gold, and Platinum didn’t increase by 100%. Silver increased by 100%, Gold and Platinum each increased by 50%. Diamond increased by 75%
Were the 2019 levels not $3K, $6K, $9K, and $15K?
I’m not saying your wrong with your analysis, just saying that anything with “marketing friendly” numbers is going to appear as an amazing coincidence based on how elite thresholds historically have been (i.e., 200% increase from level 1 to 2, 300% increase from level 1 to 3). Where DL changes this up is with their top tier.
With credit card spend, perhaps for the Platinum card. But the Reserve ratio is just the thresholds multiplied by 10.
Oh sorry, I didn’t see where you compared to 2019. I thought you were comparing to current. My bad.
In economics, it’s called price leadership.
Is that really surprising? When elite status was determined entirely by distance flown, the three major airlines has status level thresholds that pretty much matched each other, too. And everyone had a baseline domestic award for 25k miles round trip.
Any hope that the backlash may get Delta to reconsider?
After a year, expect Delta to tweak the program just as AA did one year after introducing LPs. And, don’t be surprised if there are subsequent annual tweaks in either program.
That’s embarrassingly simple from an exec earning seven figures.
To be fair, execs are paid to take the ideas they pay the consultants to give them, who just copied United who took it from probably the same consultants.