Frequent Miler's latest team challenge, Million Mile Madness, is happening now! Follow us as Greg, Nick, and Stephen compete to earn 1 Million SAS miles by flying 15 airlines before November 23rd. Who will complete the challenge with the most Speed, Affordability, and Style?
Given the current times, many readers have expressed an increased interest in vacation rentals. Greg recently wrote about Marriott’s Homes & Villas as a way to earn points while booking a vacation rental stay. However, we receive a lot of questions about using points to book a vacation rental stay. The truth is that there aren’t a lot of amazing options if you’re looking to use points to book a home or condo — but that doesn’t mean there are zero options. In this post, I’ve taken a look at a number of options that stood out to me — and I’m looking forward to reader feedback about your other hidden gem vacation rental tips.
First: The obvious (reimburse travel)
The most obvious way to handle vacation rentals using points would be using a card that offers the ability to reimburse travel purchases. For example, the Capital One® Venture® Rewards Credit Card offers the chance to offset travel purchases at a rate of 1 cent per Capital One “mile”. That means the card earns an effective 2% back toward travel purchases. Such a return is not terribly exciting given that you can get 2% back with no annual fee on a number of other cards (or even better on cards with an annual fee and/or within the first year). However, if you have a big points balance, whether from a welcome bonus or two (remember that Capital One lets you combine your own Capital One miles easily online and you can transfer to anyone else with Capital One miles over the phone with no annual caps) or from spending on the miles-earning cards, they would be easy to use for a vacation rental.
The Bank of America Travel Rewards card is cut from a similar thread as was the Barclays Arrival Plus (though that card has been unavailable for new applicants for quite some time).
Second obvious option: Using hotel points for condo properties
Many hotel chains operate condo / timeshare / apartment-style properties. For example, last year Greg reviewed a 2-bedroom option at the Waterline Marina by Marriott.
A couple of years ago, I stayed at the Conrad Fort Lauderdale, where (at the time) I was able to book a 1-bedroom unit as a standard room reward.
The bottom line is that many chains have vacation rental-like properties. However, I sense that many readers are looking for different vacation rental options than what they may see via a hotel search (and to avoid being stuck in elevators with a crowd, etc), so I’ll focus on other options in this post.
A likely best option for many: Cash out Chase points at 1.5c each
In many cases, I think the best option at the current moment will be redeeming Chase Ultimate Rewards points to “pay yourself back” for groceries. Given that Chase is currently offering members with the Chase Sapphire Reserve card the chance to redeem points to pay for grocery purchases at a value of 1.5c each, you will likely get your best value for vacation rentals via this avenue.
You could probably buy Airbnb gift cards at your grocery store and then use Chase points to pay yourself back. Alternatively, do your regular grocery shopping and put the money you would have used to pay for the groceries into a travel fund after you’ve used points to reimburse the purchase. Book your vacation rental with the money you would have spent on groceries. Another option is that you could likely buy Visa Gift Cards at the grocery store (particularly attractive if there is a current Visa or Mastercard gift card deal at your preferred grocery store chain) and then use the gift cards to pay and/or manufacture spend.
This is likely to yield one of the best values for vacation rentals. Let’s say you were going to spend $2,000 on a vacation rental for a week: that comes out to 133,333 Ultimate Rewards points at 1.5c per point — just over 19,000 points per night to pay for a rental at about $285 per night. You can obviously adjust up or down from there as fits your needs, but it’s worth repeating that it will probably be hard to beat this value toward vacation rentals.
Chase Travel Portal has some for 1.5c each
Since the Chase Ultimate Rewards travel booking portal is run by Expedia, they do have some vacation rentals available for booking straight through the portal. This saves you the step of going to the grocery store since, with the Chase Sapphire Reserve card, you can still get 1.5c per point. Just shop around and make sure that you can’t find a better deal on the same rental elsewhere (if you can, see the section above about cashing out via the grocery store).
To find these, log in to the Chase travel portal and choose “Vacation Rentals” from the travel menu at the top.
Cash out Membership Rewards at 1.25c each
I am less excited about cashing out transferable points at 1.25c each than at one and a half cents each, but neither am I excited about spending cash on a vacation rental in an environment where points are otherwise collecting dust. With that in mind, another option to consider is cashing out Membership Rewards points at a value of 1.25c each. Stephen did that last year and put together a pretty epic vacation (albeit during a time before social distancing and closing of borders).
This option is only available to those with the Schwab Platinum card — so if you don’t have that card, you’d have to be willing to spend $550 on it in order to get the ability to cash out Membership Rewards points to your Schwab account at a value of 1.25c per point. That price of admission may not make this avenue worthwhile to those who don’t already have the card.
Choice points for Bluegreen Vacations?
Link to Bluegreen Vacations search tool
I’m not sure that these are possible to book right now, but an option that has flown mostly under the radar for quite some time is using Choice Privileges points to book Bluegreen Vacations properties. These timeshare-esque options are included in the “Ascend Collection” (Choice’s semi-high-end brand). In the past, these properties have been standout values in part because in many cases they offer condo-style accommodations for hotel award stay-style prices and in part because of a strange quirk of the Choice program: at many Choice properties, you can book any room type for the same number of points. In some cases, that means you can book a multi-room suite/condo for the same number of points as a regular hotel room.
Jen at Deals We Like wrote about such a property last year where she saw the opportunity to book a 2-bedroom unit for 16,000 Choice points per night. Remember that you can buy Choice points for around three quarters of a cent per point so long as you have a few Choice points (as you’ll see in that post, even if you have no Choice points you could transfer 6K from Membership Rewards and then buy the rest of what you need for $0.0075 per point). That brings the net cost of a property like the one Jen noted to about $120 per night.
Another option to keep in mind is that if you have elite status with Amtrak or have spent $20K in a year on their credit cards, you can transfer points from Amtrak to Choice at a rate of 1:3.
Unfortunately, all this talk may be for naught: As noted above, I’m not sure it is possible to make this conversion right now. I tried a bunch of searches and couldn’t find a single day available on points at any of the Bluegreen Vacation properties I searched. I’m not sure if Choice has temporarily suspended this as a result of the COVID crisis or what, but I’m not seeing this available right now.
Wyndham Vacation rentals
Link to Wyndham Rewards Vacation Rentals search tool
During our live broadcast on Youtube on Tuesday, Greg and I tackled a question about vacation rentals and Greg mentioned the Wyndham partnership with Cottages.com and that it is unfortunate that Cottages.com only has properties in Europe. While that is true, it is worth noting that Wyndham Rewards members can also book vacation rentals in the United States using a different program.
Like with the Cottages.com partnership, Wyndham vacation rentals cost 15K points per bedroom per night. Alternatively, you can use 3K points per bedroom per night to get 20% off the nightly rate (which can be worth it if you’re short on points for the whole thing — if the nightly rate is $150 or more, you’re getting 1 cent per Wyndham point or better assuming you don’t have access to a better rate).
Unfortunately, the utility of this option may be limited. From the terms:
Go Free Home and Go Free Condo awards are subject to blackout dates and rates. (A “blackout rate” means a room rate above which a particular home, cottage or condo will not offer a Go Free Home award or Go Free Condo award.)
I don’t see a maximum rate listed, so it may vary by property.
That said, I did see some pretty cool looking properties listed. See as an example this place, which as a 1-bedroom rental should cost 15,000 points when it is available:
Southwest Rapid Rewards “More Rewards”
Here’s an option you probably haven’t considered (and probably shouldn’t, but keep in mind that I led with the fact that your best option is probably Chase points): Southwest allows you to book hotels, including what appear to be some vacation rentals, using Southwest Rapid Rewards points via the “More Rewards” feature. I think this option is only available to Rapid Rewards credit card holders as per the screen shot above.
Would you have believed me if I’d told you that you can book the Park Hyatt Beaver Creek using almost the same number of Southwest points as you would Hyatt points?
I actually found some dates where that property cost fewer than 30K points. But don’t get too excited: the Southwest price is based on low cash rates during the period in each case. Still, you can book any suite you want with Southwest points.
But I digress: the point with which I should have led this section is that you can use Southwest points to book a variety of vacation rentals. You’ll have to start here, then click “Explore More Rewards”. From there, you’ll likely have to log in and look for the rental car option — that will bring you to a booking portal where you can instead choose hotels. From there, you can narrow down to “cabins” or “condos” or “chalets”, etc.
I did not extensively search different areas, but I’d bet that there are likely some other vacation rental options to be had. For example, in Pigeon Forge, TN, I found 9 different cabins listed via Southwest:
However, I couldn’t find an available room at any of them (though I did find one listed with ten bedrooms and six bathrooms). Note that the options above were almost all available via Chase. You may note with specific interest the Sugar Plum above — which was more than 30K Southwest points per night — or about 9K Ultimate Rewards points per night during the same period as shown in the Chase section above. Southwest was a terrible deal.
I did find some condos and chalets available, including this one with 3 bedrooms that include 3 king beds and 1 twin bunk bed for 54K Southwest points per night:
I personally wouldn’t be excited about paying that many Southwest points per night (that could buy you around $800 worth of airfare), but if you’re not planning on flying anywhere for a while maybe you feel differently.
Bottom line
I was not particularly surprised to find that the best use of points for vacation rentals is in most cases going to be using Chase points — whether through the Ultimate Rewards travel portal or via the pay yourself back feature. That said, it isn’t the only option. If you’re flush with some other type of points without a more valuable use of those points in mind — whether they be Wyndham Rewards, Choice, or Southwest — you can indeed find some other vacation rental options using points. On the flip side, you may rather collect points when paying for your vacation rental this year and bank those points for a future trip.
hotels.com with discounted gift cards? AirBnB w/ discounted gcs? VIP Expedia properties for Citi cc holders?
Discounted gift cards are a great strategy, but this post was specifically about using rewards points.
Are there vacation rentals in the VIP Expedia properties?
I’ve tried to book Wyndham Vacation Rentals and they have been bought by VACASA and I have not been able to use points to book anymore
Okay, Nick, you finally convinced me to cash out Chase URs. I product changed my Preferred to Reserve today.
Our “vacation rental” is a RV rental to be able to see our 2 sons on the other side of the country. Hubby and I will use the RV as our hotel suite on wheels. We drive from Pittsburgh to Leadville, CO to see one kid. Then on to Seattle to see the other. We’ll stay in the RV even when at their houses. It will take us 4 days to drive home from Seattle, going through a couple of national parks. The trip should take 18 – 19 days total.
Hubby already has a Cap1 sign-up bonus we thought we’d use on trains in Europe. Ha! He just got approved for a biz version. The RV rental will meet the minimum spend. The two Cap1 sign-up bonuses will cover ~$1300. (I tested with the deposit. CruiseAmerica codes as car rental.)
We’ll get 5X points with the CSR on the $1500 we’ll probably spend on gas driving 5500 miles. I’m guessing campgrounds will code as travel and go against our $300 travel reimbursement. We’ll certainly buy food – groceries and dining out, which we can reimburse from our stash of URs.
Our only decision then is do we cash out more URs to indirectly reimburse ourselves for the rest of the cost of the trip? Or hang onto our URs? After listening to epidemiologists, we may not fly anywhere even in 2021. I’m leaning toward your way of thinking and will probably cash out.
We NEVER thought we’d use an RV. Such is life during Covid. CruiseAmerica will give us $3000 toward purchase of one of their used rigs after our rental. We’re old enough to have lifetime senior National Park passes. Maybe that’s what we’ll do for a couple of years until we feel safe getting on an airplane.
The (likely) reason you are having issues booking into Bluegreen Vacations is because high-priority owners are booking like mad right now, too! Bluegreen has a lot of especially desirable mountain inventory. I own with 3 different timeshare companies, and it’s tough to book exactly what you want right now cause of their increased popularity. Also, many properties are reducing the numbers of check-ins on any given day (just like hotels) due to Covid restrictions, furthering lowering available inventory.
An excellent way to book Wyndham villas/cottages is extraholidays.com. Scroll down on ALL their rates – Summer Promo rates are the best discounts right now. Great deals on 2-3 br condo/townhome units. You can find both Club Wyndham (Wyndham’s timeshare arm) and WorldMark (Wyndham purchased) leftover inventory. Both are equally nice, though WorldMark can be more spacious/newer, depending. You can earn WRs if you give them your Rewards info at booking.
Always also compare pricing with the Wyndham website. Some of these same units show on there along with the ability to use WRs. I have found, and now stayed at, some great multi-bedroom properties by clicking through both these resources. The cash rates have been so low in a couple instances ($150/nt/2-br), I have just gone ahead and paid cash, saving timeshare & WR points til 2021/22 (timeshare companies are also extending point expirations).
I have also found that if you do your homework with resorts, you can have a safe and fun experience. I have booked into first-floor patio rooms at JW & Hyatt Regencies, for instance, where my family never has to access public areas. I would check-in by myself at the front desk then go to the room and let everyone else in through the patio door. No elevators, ever. They offer acres of hiking trails and a nice change of natural scenery everyone was otherwise wanting. On-site water parks were also in full swing, but I would personally not be comfortable with that for my family.
You’ll want to check if a property is offering room service, though, if you don’t want to deal with crowded restaurants. I assumed wrong in one case – we ended up driving off the resort property for less crowds at mealtime which actually ended up great with trying some iconic places. I can vouch that Marriott, Hyatt, & Wyndham were being so very careful & compliant and so were the other guests. There are always exceptions, but our masks were on as soon as we left our rooms and we have had no issues.
Real time rewards via the altitude reserve deserve a mention, no?
Small point to add that Choice points are on sale right now. Even if you think you will not use them now, if you might in the future, it is a good opportunity to seed your account now with 6,000 points (for $49.50), which will give you the ability to “buy” points in the future if points plus cash is available, and can save transferring Amex at a bad rate.
Great point!
I’m surprised you don’t include the Barclaycard Arrival +. It’s lost value, given that the 10% back on points use for travel dropped to 5% a few years ago.
But we use it enough to justify the the AF, and can stay wherever we want. Which tends to be boutique hotels. And when you prefer off the beaten path, 2.05 cents per dollar works great for hotels, rental cars, etc, without worrying about matching hotel points to where you want to go.
Be surprised no longer — take a look at the flexible point section and you’ll see that I included it after all :-). Here’s the sentence you missed:
“The Bank of America Travel Rewards card is cut from a similar thread as was the Barclays Arrival Plus (though that card has been unavailable for new applicants for quite some time).”
Nick,
I think you might be missing one but otherwise love the writeup! As one who has Cap1 “miles” the new Accor partnership allows you to buy gift cards for onefinestay, which is part of Accor, at a cash out rate of 1.53 cents per point (changes due to the value of the euro). They have some very nice vacation homes to pick from.
I actually looked into this, but I couldn’t figure out whether or how you could use Accor points to pay for these. Do you know that you can use points for those?
On the ALL page, looks like you pick your destination property in step 1 and redeem your loyalty points for a onefinestay gift card in step 2.
I’ve unsuccessfully tried to use Ultimate Rewards’ travel portal to find vacation rentals. Every time that I’ve searched for rentals, every single rental is “not available”. Yet, when I go to AirBnB or VRBO the same rental would show as available. It got so frustrating that I quit even trying to go that route. I do like the idea of grocery store gift cards to pay, though. Thanks!
I’ve heard that from other readers, too. Funny enough, the one I used as an example here (specifically because it was also available via Southwest and was in the same location as the Wyndham example) was available through Chase.
Great article, Nick. I just keep learning so many things from you guys! You are always so thorough and provide the reasoning behind options.